Botched Circumcision

In 1973 the story became known of an infant boy whose penis had been irreparably damaged during circumcision ten years earlier. His parents, after consultation with medical experts at Johns Hopkins Medical School, determined that it was in the boy’s best interests to be reared as a girl. But even with hormone treatments and surgically created female genitals, he hated to wear girls’ clothing, played with guns and insisted on using the toilet while standing. In spite of these contradictory behaviors, the case was cited in research texts and journals on sexuality as proof that sexual identity is not fixed at birth but is more fluid and dependent on environmental or social factors. In fact, twenty years ago his case was used widely in professional and popular media to support sex reassignment as appropriate for males with deformed, ambiguous or injured genitals.

The New York Times, along with articles in Time (March 24, 1997 p. 49) and The Washington Post (March 18, 1997, section Z, page 7) summarized the full story which appeared in the Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine. In that journal, Drs. Milton Diamond and H. Keith Sigmundson presented an in-depth follow-up report that flatly contradicts earlier conclusions in the case.

Drs. Diamond and Sigmundson wrote that, “despite everyone telling him constantly that he was a girl, and despite his being treated with female hormones, his brain knew he was a male. It refused to take on what it was being told.” In addition, Diamond said in an interview, “It’s easy for us to modify genitals. But we can’t modify the brain. That’s what this kid proves.”

Excerpts taken from Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood: Journal for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood Volume 2. Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, 1996, 1997; 2002, S. 2:2

This “botched circumcision” account above shows that masculinity and femininity are ultimately “inborn,” or essential. Arguments have been made that masculinity and femininity are a product of how a child is raised and how society impacts him or her. That’s not what happened to the young man even with hormone treatment, surgery, and his parents and society trying to raise him as a girl. To me, this puts to rest all arguments that say that masculinity and femininity are a product of how children are raised and how society impacts them. Society and upbringing may confuse a child about his masculinity or her femininity, but it cannot change how the child was innately born i.e. masculine or feminine.

More information about this account can be found in the book entitled: As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised As A Girl (P.S.) by John Colapinto, Harper Collins Publishers, 2006.

About the author

TimTrautman

Hi, I'm Tim Trautman, an aspiring blogger with a special sensitivity to issues surrounding Masculinity and Femininity. This blog is designed to make readers aware of the issues and grant a healthy understanding of what Masculinity and Femininity are.

View all posts

8 Comments

  • It looks like other sorts of web page homeowners
    should take this web site as being an model type,
    fairly tidy and impressive owner friendly style,
    as well as articles. You’re an experienced within this area!

    • Thank you for your kind words! I was fortunate to find a good blog format to house this topic that I’ve been working with for years.

  • It is the best time to make some plans for the future and
    it’s time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting things or advice.
    Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article.
    I desire to read even more things about it! I will immediately take hold
    of your rss feed as I can not to find your e-mail subscription link or e-newsletter service.
    Do you have any? Please permit me recognise in order that I could
    subscribe. Thanks. I have been browsing online more than three hours
    as of late, yet I never discovered any interesting
    article like yours. It is lovely value enough for me.
    Personally, if all webmasters and bloggers made excellent content material as you did, the internet can be a lot more useful than ever before.

    • Thank you for your interest in Masculinity and Femininity 101! Your suggestions of an RSS feed and subscription/e-newsletter are very good. In response, I have just started an RSS feed and will work out any kinks in it as they show up. As far as putting together an email subscription or e-newsletter, I will likely need both and that will take some time to set up. That will be my next project. Finally, I will write more articles that reference this article and that apply to events that are happening today. Thank you for your comment!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *